Get my weekly newsletter with the latest hobby updates delivered straight to your inbox! Jim Lansford wasn't a great football player, but its the scarcity of his 1952 Bowman Large card that makes it so valuable. He was known for his ability to prepare and dominate each game before taking an NFL snap, where he was already being compared to the great Johnny Unitas. Brett Favre threw for over 3,000 passing yards in 18 straight seasons, an NFL record he shares with Tom Brady. Leo Nomellini was a Hall of Fame football player who spent his entire 14-year career with the San Francisco 49ers. Warner remains the only player ever to be inducted into both the AFL and NFL. In fourteen years with the Pittsburgh Steelers, Bradshaw led his team to 4 Super Bowl Championships, while winning 2 Super Bowl MVPs. Lane's rookie in Excellent condition can be found for around $50, a true bargain in my opinion. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Dunlop was a reserve player so the value is solely based on the scarcity of the card itself. He remains an advocate for the school and continues to give back to the Volunteer community while honoring students, staff members, and upgrading school facilities. 4 John Elway #21: Funny enough, Elway never had a 30-TD season. PSA has graded only around 100 copies of his rookie card, making this one of the scarcer cards in the set. However, Peyton chose another SEC team where he became the league's leading passer with 11,201 yards. As mentioned earlier, Dickerson's card was ultimately pulled from production due to contract disputes, but not before some found their way into packs. Unitas had a 54.6 completion percentage, where Peyton had a 65.3% completion percentage. Bradshaw was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility in 1989. For more information, read our. Other cards from the set are still pricey, with cards ranging from $300 to $1000 in Good condition. Thus if you want a Bradshaw rookie in a lower grade it will be easy to find and relatively inexpensive. When his NFL career came to an end, he set school records in passing yards, completions, and touchdowns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. He was one of the last two-way full-timers in the NFL, playing both Center and Middle Linebacker. The 1989-1990 Topps Football Card Collection is the most expensive sports card ever sold at auction, selling for $407,500 in August 2010. 'Slingin' Sammy Baugh is well regarded as one of the best quarterbacks of all time. Required fields are marked *. As a 126 card set, this 1998 SP Authentic card has an unusually generous print run for a card of such high value. This card features Tony Gonzalez's rarest and most sought after card due to the limited amount produced with a print run of only 150. POP 6, KENNY PICKETT 2022 PANINI CONTENDERS OPTIC CRACKED ICE ROOKIE TICKET RC AUTO /22, 1997 Skybox Premium Football Rubies Rookie #220SR Warrick Dunn /50, 2022 Donruss Optic Brock Purdy GOLD Downtown RC - 1/10 - eBay 1/1 PSA 9 MINT, 2017 Panini Plates & Patches Patrick Mahomes II Ruby Rookie Patch Auto 5/5 #217, 2000 Playoff Contenders Tom Brady Rookie Autograph SP Round #s PSA 9 Auto , 1986 FLEER BASKETBALL MICHAEL JORDAN ROOKIE #57 - Authentic NICE!!. The set includes all eight regular season games as well as the two playoff rounds. PSA has only graded 20 PSA 9 copies, with 3 PSA 10 (Gem Mint) all the while grading a grand total of over 3000 Bradshaw rookie cards. As Bill Belichick notes in the video below, Baugh was the equal of Tom Brady, Ed Reed, and Brian Moorman all wrapped into one. The population for this card is only four, where only two of them have been sold. However, he eventually became entangled with cocaine use and after failing his third drug test, the NFL suspended him in 1989. #afflink #advertising When you click on links to various merchants in this video description and make a purchase, this can result in this channel earning a c. The reason behind the scarcity of the card is unknown, but likely that Mayo pulled the card after realizing that they failed to print Dunlop's name on the front of the card. Rockne's card is the second most valuable card in the set (behind Nagurski) and in mint condition is worth $16,500. Good condition Nagurski cards will likely set you back close to $20,000. Layne led the Detroit Lions to three titles and was a six-time pro bowler. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Steve 'Big Boy' Van Buren's 1948 Leaf rookie card has five, yes FIVE different variations. While not many 1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars cards have surfaced, this Peyton Manning card is on the weaker side in terms of condition sensitivity. When all was said and done, Favre broke every school record imaginable. His rookie season also featured the worst record in his career, where the Colts went 3-13. Peyton keeps the list rolling with this 1998 E-X2001 card. $42.0 1990 Score #145 Steve Young by Score from 1990 with a value of approx. How do I determine the value of these cards and once they are valued where do you sell them? 2. CharlieConerly was an excellent football player (although not quite good enough for the Hall of Fame). He remains the only person to ever be selected as both an NFL Pro Bowler and MLB All-Star. This card's total population is 10, and the highest grade obtained is a nine from both PSA and BGS. Regardless of value, though, these cards bring plenty of nostalgia to collectors who grew up collecting them. I'm sure readers are familiar with Rockne's 'Win One For The Gipper' speech which helped propel Notre Dame to an upset win over Navy. Unbelievable to think that Bart Starr was a 17th round draft pick of the Green Bay Packers in 1956. If you grew up collecting Bo Jackson cards, playing Super Mario Brothers on the NES and longing for a pair of Air Jordans, there's a good . Copyright 2022 - All Vintage Cards - All Rights Reserved. The substance abuse variation, being rarer, can be worth quite a bit in high grade. Since the card's release in 1997, this card's total population is two, with the highest grade earning a BGS 8. 1998 Finest shares that Peyton could be the best Colts quarterback since Johnny Unitas, a Baltimore Colts great, and one of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time. Collectors are willing to overpay for this card when they arise due to the card's appeal how and sparingly this card appears. I hope you enjoy reading the list as much as I did creating it! Hidden Gems: Top 10 Undervalued 70s Baseball Rookie Cards, Hidden Gems: Top 10 Vintage NBA Rookie Cards To Invest In, The 12 Most Valuable Upper Deck Young Guns Hockey Cards, The 10 Most Valuable Cards In The 1949 Bowman Baseball Set, 2022 Panini Select Football Brock Purdy Black Color Wheel Rookie RC 1/1 PSA 8, Dante Lavelli signed 1950 Bowmen Rookie Card Football Hall of Fame PSA/DNA, Jalen Hurts 2020 Prizm Football White Sparkle Prizm SSP Rookie Card BGS 9.5, 2020 Contenders Optic Joe Burrow Rookie Ticket Auto Red /199 Cincinnati Bengals, 1971 Topps Football #156 Terry Bradshaw Steelers RC Rookie HOF PSA 7 " PWCC-S ", Joe Burrow 2020 Prizm Football Rookie Auto Silver Prizm RC BGS 9.5 / 10, 2022 Panini One Football Kenny Pickett Rookie Patch Auto RPA #/50 Fractal #386, 2017 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Optic Auto Black Holo #/25, *6424 - Michael Jordan - 1986-87 Fleer #8 Stickers RC Rookie BGS 9.5 GEM MINT, 2022 Select Football Erik Ezukanma Rookie Shield Patch Auto Black 1/1 PACK FRESH, 1997 Skybox Premium Football Rubies Rookie #212SR Tiki Barber /50, 2021 Panini Donruss Trevor Lawrence Downtown RC ROOKIE #DT-33 PSA 9 NFL QB TLaw, Donruss Optic Football 2022 Brock Purdy Rookie Downtown Black Pandora /25 DT-BP, 2020 Panini Origins Booklet Rookie Auto JOE BURROW/JALEN HURTS/JORDAN LOVE 2/5, Select Football 2022 Brock Purdy Rookie Field Level Green Checkerboard /5 493 RC, 2022 PANINI CHRONICLES BROCK PURDY ROOKIE PRIZM BLACK BLUE SP #/25 49ERS #PB-8, 1979 Panini Diego Maradona Italian Football Rookie Card RC #312. Your email address will not be published. The following year, Kurt Warner took the St. Lous Rams to Super Bowl victory. This card's total population from BGS and PSA sits at 11, with the highest graded card being a BGS 9. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network and Amazon Associates Affiliate Program. Shop Now eBay. Rice was the 16th overall selection in the 1985 NFL Draft and was a three-time Super Bowl champion with the San Francisco 49ers. After Dickerson refused to let other card manufacturers use his name and likeness, the NFLPA asked Pro Set to remove it from its set production and distribution. His rookie card pictures him still in his University of Miami uniform but it was with the Seattle Seahawks where he carved out his strong legacy and Hall of Fame career. There are eight cards from the 1948 Leaf Set on this list, making it one of most prized (and expensive) vintage football sets in the hobby. Anticipating a Raiders and 49ers Super Bowl showdown, Pro Set decided to print these "Super Bowl XXV" cards for twelve members of each team. He was one of the last two-way full-timers in the NFL, playing both Center and Middle Linebacker. He played quarterback for the New York Giants from 1948 to 1961. won rookie of the year in 1948 and MVP in 1959 while also winning the NFL Championship with the Giants in 1956, found more popularity in later life, taking on the 'Marlboro Man' persona in various cigarette advertisements (one. Lane set a record as a rookie in 1952 with 14 interceptions, a mark that still hasn't been surpassed to this day. Barry Sander's card from 1997 Metal Universe has a population of 11, all of which were graded by BGS. Read our methodology . The 1966 Philadelphia Gum set is one of the most popular in the hobby, due to the slick and clean design, along with the rookie cards of both Dick Butkus and Gale Sayers. The card's total population remains at six, and only one card has a higher grade than this BGS 9 than sold for $6,500 in October. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Leaf produced two versions of Layne's rookie card, one with him wearing yellow pants and another with red pants. The electrifying running back is a member of the 2,000-yard club, which is exclusive to only seven NFL running backs who eclipsed 2,000 rushing yards in a single season. If you can 'imagine John Riggins in a leather helmet..playing in the 1940's' as detailed in the below video produced by NFL Films, then that's what Van Buren is best recognized as. In 13 years as head coach of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish, Rockne led his team to 3 championships, with five undefeated seasons. It's no surprise of the significant demand for Nagurski's Chicle rookie card. However, Peyton Manning's career stats far exceed those of Unitas. PSA has a great writeup of the set which discusses how Philadelphia Gum won the rights to produce NFL football cards (away from Topps) from 1964 to 1967. A Mint condition Baugh will set you back big bucks,but one in Good condition can be found for around $500. Bednarik's 1948 Leaf rookie card is the second most valuable issue in the star studded set(behind Layne) with a Mint copy estimated to be worth $30,000. Each short summary gives a brief explanation of the history of the card, what makes it so valuable, and is accompanied by a look at the card itself. A 1990 Pro set PSA rated gem mint 10 card of really good quality. The card has been graded 10 times by PSA, which features just one card earned a PSA 10. Ungraded & graded values for all '90 Topps Football Cards. McCants wound up in Tampa as the number four pick overall. Leaf produced two versions of Layne's rookie card, one with him wearing yellow pants and another with red pants. Peyton left such an impact on the University of Tennesse that the school renamed a street after him, called Peyton Manning Pass. The price difference is due to the rarity of the cards. . Many call it one of the all-time great Peyton Manning cards. With its multi-colored borders, football graphic in the lower-left, and green and white gridiron notches on the top and bottom borders, this set is instantly recognizable. Needless to say, he was the first pick in the 1998 NFL Draft. In fact, this makes it the most valuable football card ever. Peyton also nearly has double the number of passing yards and touchdowns as Unitas. Pro Set eventually caught the issue and fixed it with a bit of airbrush magic. Conerly's 1948 Leaf rookie card is a hot card among vintage football card collectors, especially Giants fans. He won two championships, six All-Pro nominations, and led the league in completion percentage in eight years, In 1943 he accomplished the unthinkable, leading the league in passing, punting, and interceptions (as a defensive back), As Bill Belichick notes in the video below, Baugh was the equal of Tom Brady, Ed Reed, and Brian Moorman all wrapped into one, There are eight cards from the 1948 Leaf Set on this list, making it one of most prized (and expensive) vintage football sets in the hobby, Walker's '48 Leaf Rookie card isn't scarce, as over 200 PSA copies exist, although a Mint copy is tough to come by and valued at $15,000, however can be found quite easily for less than $100, Walker had the shortest career (six seasons) of any player in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, yet his six years as a player were quite remarkable, Waterfield's 1948 Leaf rookie card has two variations: white lettering (much scarcer) and black lettering. Very informative blog. 1989 Score Barry Sanders RC By the time 1989 rolled around, print runs were soaring. And there are likely to be some undiscovered variations still lurking out there that will keep master set collectors on their toes for years to come. Top 100 Football Cards 100. Like other players of the day, Nomellini also wrestled in the off-season under the moniker Leo 'The Lion' Monellini. Although Jackson would be named a Pro Bowler for the 1990 season, his football career was cut short because of an injury he suffered against the Bengals (oddly the same opposing team on this card) in 1991. But, again, to be worth much they'll need to be professionally graded in gem mint condition. As part of that trade to secure Jeff George with the first pick of the 1990 NFL Draft, Indianapolis sent a young Andre Rison to Atlanta. Seau was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2015 and today, his rookie card is one of the keys to this set. Here's Tittle in 1962 shredding the Redskins for 7 touchdowns and over 500 yards passing. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The close-up shot of Peyton is what makes this card attractive along with a large signature. The Colts took a shot on Unitas and it paid off handsomely. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. He averaged just under 100 rushing yards per game over his career with 99.8 rushing yards per game while rushing for precisely 5 yards per carry. 1980 Topps Jack Lambert (#280) Jack Lambert first took the field as a Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker in 1974. For those collectors on the lookout for great Hall of Famers of the era or just a fun set to complete, I would advise putting together the basic checklist. Upon reinstatement, he played four games for the Cardinals in 1990 and fourteen games for the Buccaneers in 1991. Issued in plugs of tobacco, the Mayo cards are hard to find in good condition mostly because of the black borders which are prone to chipping. The relative scarcity versus the Gale Sayers rookie card from the same set, gives the Butkus the advantage from a value standpoint. If you ever saw Barry Sanders play, you know he was incredibly fast and could stop and cut on a dime leaving defenders grabbing at nothing but air. PSA has only graded 130 Lansford cards, where on average, star players have numbers closer to the 200 range. Only 5 have been awarded a PSA 9 rating, hence the reason for the quarter of a million-dollar valuation. As a result, prices of the 1989 Score Barry Sanders, the running back's most popular rookie, have softened in recent years. Based on my research there are likely only around 10 of the Dunlop cards in existence, making this scarcer than a T206 Honus Wagner. Reggie White's card is one of the rarest cards on the list and has a population of three, all of which were graded by BGS. Nomellini's 1948 Leaf rookie card has two variations--one with Nomellini in a red jersey and another in a maroon jersey. Unfortunately, his struggles with cocaine continued and he retired in 1991 after failing his fourth drug test. Some of those also included a special message from Ludwell Denny on the reverse side. This could make it a bargain in the years to come as there's lots of room for growth once again. He made his rookie card debut in the 1989 Score set but collectors still look for this second-year card in high grade as well. Randy Moss holds the record for most touchdown catches in a single season with 23 and trails only Jerry Rice for most touchdowns in NFL history. Layne was a great leader on and off the field, even if it might have not exactly been the norm as compared to the NFL of today: "When Bobby said block, you blocked," said another former teammate and Hall of Famer, Yale Lary. Although Bart Starr's rookie card is the most valuable in the 1957 Topps set, the 1957 Topps Johnny Unitas rookie card isn't too far behind. One of the rare collections of Match Attax cards is the special one hundred football club card collection. The late McNair was offered a scholarship at the University of Florida to play running back but desired to play quarterback, so he competed for Alcorn State University in Mississippi. Certified PSA 6, 2017 Certified RPA Rookie Patch AUTO PATRICK MAHOMES II PSA 9 MINT CHIEFS! Michael Strahan holds the lead for most sacks in a season with 22.5, though he did that throughout a complete 16 game season. Estimated Super Bowl XXV PSA 10 Value: $250, Estimated Super Bowl XXV PSA 10 Value: $50. He won two championships, six All-Pro nominations, and led the league in completion percentage in eight years. When all was said and done, Favre broke every school record imaginable. In 1943 he accomplished the unthinkable, leading the league in passing, punting, and interceptions (as a defensive back). Some might not be familiar with Dick "Night Train" Lane, who in his thirteen-year playing career was known as one of the most feared tacklers in the game. The card which sold for $5,000 back in October was a BGS 8, so you could only envision what one of BGS or PSA's graded 9's would be deserving. Need help buying or selling cards or have a general question about the hobby? In fact, he never rushed for fewer than 1,115 yards, and that came during an injury-shortened season in 1993 in which he only played eleven games. Heading into the 1990 season, Bo Jackson was arguably the hottest name in sports. Jim Brown's rookie card is the most valuable card in the 1958 Topps football card set and one of the most highly desired among all football card collectors. This Peyton Manning card's eye appeal is off the charts, making this card's value remain secure. The legendary Bo Jackson appears on two different 1990 Pro Set cards: one celebrating him and the AFC Champion Raiders headed to Super Bowl XXV and the other classic, more recognizable black-bordered base card. (725) 4.99. Peyton's 1998 Finest card was limited to 75 copies, a refractor card that features a protective coating. Tarkenton was one of the first true scramblers as he had the quickness and dexterity to easily evade defenders, even earning the moniker, the Mad Scrambler. Those kids who grew up idolizing Jackson are now adults full of nostalgia and they still look for his cards in high grade. Brown pretty much shattered every running record when he retired. Known as one of the best passers, punters, and place-kickers in the NFL, Waterfield was an all-around great. So, for the cards on this list to be worth much, they'll have to be graded by PSA to be in perfect, gem mint condition. The most valuable Card of Steve Young is currently 1984 Topps USFL #52 Steve Young PSA 10 by Topps from 1984 with a worth of approx. Nagurski was a big man, and at 6'3" and 235 pounds, he used to demolish opposing players when he played fullback while attacking with a vengeance on defense. Christy Mathewson 1910 T206 Dark Cap PSA 1. Learn more. If you don't want to spend the near $12K for a Mint copy,shoot for a good version condition of the card can be found for $50 or less. Of the 90 cards that have surfaced, 24 of them have been auctioned. If you are looking for something in the Good to VG range you can normally find one for under $300. Marvel Comics published the series in 1991, which centers around Phil Grayfield, a former All-American linebacker turned sports interviewer, who obtains an indestructible football uniform that he wears to fight crime. Tarkentons rookie card is also subject to the condition issues of the 62 Topps set; only 6 have earned a PSA 9 grade, although over 1000 have been graded by PSA. However, his achievements came from his life after football, where he became a wrestling sensation and one of the most influential actors in Hollywood, who will be inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in the near future. While leading the NFL in receiving touchdowns in five different seasons, Randy Moss was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2018. Rockne even helped popularize the forward pass in football.