how did cobb and saito get out of limbohow did cobb and saito get out of limbo

The second time, it's in the first . Did Cobb and Saito get out of limbo? Is there any particular reason to only include 3 out of the 6 trigonometry functions? And by the way, Cobb didn't lock the spinning top away. What is the earliest sci-fi work to reference the Titanic? Why did Cobb ask Ariadne for the secret passage in the third-level dream? Teen builds a spaceship and gets stuck on Mars; "Girl Next Door" uses his prototype to rescue him and also gets stuck on Mars. She was a danger to everyone else that joined a shared dream world with him. Firstly, it's worth stressing that Cobb was never fooled by Limbo and (initially) neither was Mal. Beaches can be hundreds of miles long. Uber in Germany (esp. Cobb drowns here. I accept dying in limbo sends you back a level, since there's nowhere else to go, but that only gets him to level 3. How long Cobb and Mal were in Limbo remains unclear to many who've seen Inception, which is just one of the movie's biggest mysteries. The opening and closing scenes in limbo, thus, are two halves of the same scene. How did Cobb go about finding Saito in limbo? rev2023.6.29.43520. Is it usual and/or healthy for Ph.D. students to do part-time jobs outside academia? [Inception] How was Cobb able to get out of Limbo? That's a bloody good question and one that isn't explicitly answered. To me, this scene is so much more powerful if Cobb has been in limbo for years, than if he had just gotten there. How did Cobb manage to go to sleep and dream to save Saito after Mal's death? (I use quotes since, as the movie has made plain in previous scenes,. " Did I read it right??? Perhaps the gambit they use against Saito where they pretend to be friendly Extractors pitching to train a wealthy individual to defend against extraction work well against a mark who is not expecting it. And Cobb reminds Saito by giving him the totem - Saito remembers to spin it. How long did Cobb spend looking for Saito? Does Saito wake up in Inception? By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Why does Cobb and Ariadne remember their mission once they drop into limbo to fischer? Considering the time difference between limbo and actual time, they had enough time to practice it. Was the phrase "The world is yours" used as an actual Pan American advertisement? How long were Cobb and Saito in limbo? Does a constant Radon-Nikodym derivative imply the measures are multiples of each other? When did this happen? and our 1.) The reason Saito looks older is because (1) he was already older than Cobb in real life, and (2) Leo is too important of an actor to use a double. How to professionally decline nightlife drinking with colleagues on international trip to Japan? It only takes a minute to sign up. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. Saito is old because those minutes . Saito was already in the limbo state due to his death in upper dream level whilst sleeping in reality. It's inconsistent. Updated Feb 25, 2023 Years after Inception first released, the "Limbo" subplot continues to confuse many people. Is Logistic Regression a classification or prediction model? Do you just have to kill yourself? How old is Saito inception? Had Cobb started training them to escape Limbo, it would have raised a considerable number of questions that he doesn't want to answer, most obviously "Why do we need such extreme training if this is supposed to be such a simple op?" Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. What is the earliest sci-fi work to reference the Titanic? The second thing to realize is: when they meet, Cobb and Saito have both forgotten they are dreaming. How do Cobb's children know which hotel he's staying at in Kyoto in Inception. Asked by: Anabelle Predovic. Thats more doable than keeping Saito alive for a week on the first level with a bullet wound on his chest. polyester. Did Cobb Get Out Of Limbo? Ignoring any out-of-universe answers, the simplest explanations are: Cobb briefly left Limbo when Mal died (possibly but highly unlikely) Cobb was so distracted when Mal died that it somehow resulted in him returning to Limbo location #1, the Beach (possible but unlikely) Cobb has spent years searching Limbo for Saito's fortress. Saito reminds Cobb by saying "a half-remembered dream" - notice the look of realization on Cobb's face when that happens. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. COBB: Its not so bad at first, being gods. What do gun control advocates mean when they say "Owning a gun makes you more likely to be a victim of a violent crime."? How did Cobb and Saito actually manage to get out of limbo and return to the plane? What was the symbol used for 'one thousand' in Ancient Rome? As Cobb was already in limbo state, there was no need for him to go to sleep there and dream. The order of events goes like this: After years of searching, Cobb finally finds Saito, who has been waiting for him. No, I think after decades of wandering, Cobb has only a vague idea he is looking for Saito, and Saito has only a vague idea he is waiting for someone. He clearly didn't catch the kick, because he would have just gone with Ariadne instead of convincing her to leave him. Published by Jennifer Webster on November 29, 2022 Cobb and Saito got out of limbo by waiting until the sedative ran out (and they were normal-asleep) then they shot themselves, thus waking up. How do Cobb and Ariadne enter Limbo without having to die? (Saito couldn't have survived even the first level of dream since the first level itself was of 1 week duration). In the train scene, when Saito was having information extracted by Cobb, the extraction team were using a two layer dream. This belonged to someone I knew, someone in a half-remembered dream.". I'm still dreaming. It is implied Saito killed Cobb and himself and he woke up. LaTeX3 how to use content/value of predefined command in token list/string. He made a huge sacrifice by staying there. The first time Cobb was there with Mal, it seems they woke up by killing themselves, by getting hit by the train. How did Cobb come to the basement using the elevator? ways. But i don't understand how Saito found that he was in a dream in the second layer, when Cobb and Arthur explaining about how they could defend against extraction to Saito at the hotel? Why does the present continuous form of "mimic" become "mimicking"? Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. It only takes a minute to sign up. How do Cobol's agents know Cobb was in the Mombasa motel? Australia to west & east coast US: which order is better? Grappling and disarming - when and why (or why not)? Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. One of the keys to the film is that as he watched Mal slide into depression at being unable to escape from Limbo, [[[he eventually used inception on her to make her think that Limbo was the real world.]]] The problem is knowing that its not real. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? He and Saito were both there for decades. Something went wrong. Someone in -", Cobb cuts Saito off and repeats the key phrase that reminded him - "someone in a half-remembered dream.". They return to real life voluntarily by killing themselves, and their minds are saved. 2.) Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! 1 Biography 2 Abilities 3 Quotes 4 Trivia 5 Gallery Biography Saito accompanies Cobb and his team on the job he hired them to do and in some ways helps plan it; when finding a place to sedate Fischer to get him into the dream world, Saito buys out an airline so the team can accompany Robert Fischer on the 10-hour flight to Los Angeles. Why does Saito want inception? so they'd fall back to limbo again? One of the keys to the film is that as Mal refused to countenance leaving Limbo (and knowing that if he did so alone that it could result in her insanity), he eventually used inception on her to make question whether Limbo was really real. He just spinned the top and left it in its usual location, the locker, so that when Mal discovers it again, she'll realize that Limbo is not real. In the movie, we see that the scene right after the van sinks is with Cobb waking up on the beach. You have lived up to your reputation, Mr. Cobb. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Does the paladin's Lay on Hands feature cure parasites? If the world with crumbling buildings is Cobb's Limbo, what is the place he ends up in with Saito? Over a decade since the movie's theatrical release, many still wonder why Saito is old at the end of Inception. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. If so then isn't it not that daunting to fall into Limbo? Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Latest Blog Post: The First Officer: Alpha Protocol Book 2, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023. Why is Saito so much older than Cobb? In the opening and closing scenes, Cobb clearly has makeup on intended to make him look older. The safe and the top are metaphors of Mal's subconscious. . But he has no idea where Saito would end up, and limbo is implied to be huge. Cologne and Frankfurt). 5 11 comments Best [deleted] 5 yr. ago They don't wanna go to limbo because when you're there you don't know that you're in limbo, you just think it's real life and can get stuck. It's arguable that Inception's ending is a conscious visual Limbo, designed to trap the viewer. I don't think they could have used any 'hospitals' since the doctors would have been Fisher's projections. Is ending of inception a dream? GDPR: Can a city request deletion of all personal data that uses a certain domain for logins? - Quora Answer (1 of 2): I think that the movie well established that Cobb is one of the experts about Limbo, and deeper dream levels, so maybe he knows a way that wasn't shown in the movie. At this point, he has entered Limbo years after Saito. @BimanTripathy "so that when Mal discovers it again" - I don't think that's necessary. Notice in the opening scene, Cobb sits down to eat with Saito. Mal did so. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Right now. While entering a new dream level, how do the characters in the shared dream know they're in a dream? It would still have worked out fine for Cobb. Does Cobb stay in limbo? For more information, please see our Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. When they meet, the remind each other why they are there. 1.) Neither remember anything more. Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Statement from SO: June 5, 2023 Moderator Action. All rights reserved. Does the Frequentist approach to forecasting ignore uncertainty in the parameter's value? Many ask why Saito is so much older than Cobb in limbo at the end. Cobb suddenly recalls all of the events that brought him there, which are shown to the audience as the length of the movie. They spent days training how to carry on the mission and spent weeks of 'dream hours' planning it. Why it is called "BatchNorm" not "Batch Standardize"? Cobb finds Saito, very old, and both kill themselves (reaching reality) When the van in level-1 sinks, Cobb drowns, and re-enters Limbo. Contents. How should I ask my new chair not to hire someone? The problem is knowing that it's not real. - Caniry She was there to witness Cobb's elevator of memories; Cobb revealed Mal's suicide to her; and she was there when Cobb finally had his realization that he had to let Mal go. After the scene that sees Cobb and Saito (seem to) wake up from Limbo, Nolan very purposefully shifts Inception into an ambiguous state that leaves it open to the viewer's perception and interpretation of that perception - two big themes of the movie, coincidentally enough. How does one transpile valid code that corresponds to undefined behavior in the target language? Reddit, Inc. 2023. Many ask why Saito is so much older than Cobb in limbo at the end. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. The beach just . Remember? Why is Mal in Cobb's dream? "It's my subconscious. A journey into limbo features a harrowing, emotional confrontation between Cobb and Mal as "they" sort out "their" issues. 3.) Cookie Notice Why do CRT TVs need a HSYNC pulse in signal? It became impossible for me to live like that. So the first thing to realize is: Cobb stayed in limbo after Ariadne left. Published Apr 5, 2023 Inception saw Cobb rescuing Saito from Limbo, but the latter had aged many, many decades in a short amount of time, while Cobb remained young. Here's why Saito ages much faster than Cobb. How AlphaDev improved sorting algorithms? It's reasonable to presume that their ability to remain conscious and lucid within Limbo is much higher than that of the others that they took into the dream with them, especially Saito and Ariadne who've had less than a few weeks exposure. And he dies again in limbo when shot by Saito, and then wakes up in reality directly. Cobb and Saito were both in limbo for the same amount of time (explanation inside) I just watched Inception for the first time and wanted to share an interpretation that doesn't seem popular but makes a lot of sense to me. How long did Cobb spend in limbo with Saito? OSPF Advertise only loopback not transit VLAN. . How did Saito get into . Cobb and Saito got out of limbo by waiting until the sedative ran out (and they were normal-asleep) then they shot themselves, thus waking up. becoming insane). Have a look at the edit. > How did Cobb go about finding Saito in limbo? You can also ask how could they go to sleep in turmoil in different levels. Why is the Limbo at the end of the film filled with Cobb & Mal's city? Why was Cobb so afraid to go into limbo, if he had already gone there and knows that he can use his totem to get out? Stained and frayed in such distinctive What happens to Robert Fischer in the limbo and third level dream states? I'm lying on 1960s? Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. In the train scene, when Saito was having information extracted by Cobb, the extraction team were using a two layer dream. Are you asking how did he not know he was being extracted in the Hotel layer (where Mal intercepted), or how did he not know he was being extracted in the Riot layer (where he discovers the carpet is fake)? I've added more details in the question. Did Cobb stay in limbo at the end? He took the spinning top and locked it away (on its side in the safe in her old house) so that she would question whether Limbo. How did Cobb and Saito return from Limbo. So, Cobb dies in the fourth level once, and dies in limbo too. I think he's been swimming up and down that beach for years looking for Saito. Why is Saito much older than Cobb in Limbo? UPDATED 8/2 At 12:21PM PST How did Mal get involved in all the dream invasion stuff to begin with? 2.) Or is this just a dead give away that they are still stuck dreaming (in limbo?) How is it that Robert Fisher could have been killed by his own projections? It became impossible for me to live like that. So how does he go from limbo to level 3, then to level 2, then to level 1, then back to limbo again? How does Ariadne know that Saito is dead in the upper level? He knew by going there alone, he would be lost for a long time and might not even make it back, but he did it to save Saito so their agreement could be honored and he could enter the US and see his kids. If dying in level 3 gets him back to 2, and dying in 2 gets him back to 1, then dying in 1 wouldn't send him to limbo. Neither remember why. COBB: It's not so bad at first, being gods. I'm not exactly sure what you're asking. Therefore, Cobb and Saito would have been trapped in limbo for 182 years if they hadn't been kicked out of the dream. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. He should have been like "oh sh**.. but ok, I'll go to limbo and get him back." In Inception, how does the machine determine who are the Dreamer and Subject? Why is Saito so much older than Cobb in limbo? - Quora. Why should he be worried about someone falling into Limbo if he can just go and rescue them? But how did Cobb realized he was in limbo, when he and Mal were stuck there? Would limited super-speed be useful in fencing? How did Cobb get Saito out? This is also the scene where we are introduced to Mal, she speaks to Cobb as he begins his attempt to break into the safe, and then enters the room with Saito and Arthur at gunpoint. I've watched the movie over and over again did I miss it? "Have you come to kill me? Updated Feb 25, 2023 Cobb and Mal might have spent decades in limbo, but that's equal to less than a day in the waking world, according to the rules of Inception. Saito repeats himself to Cobb, who has been staring into space for a while as he remembers. How did Cobbs crew know about Saitos apartment? @BimanTripathy - I don't think I was being very clear. The first time, the words are those of Saito (Ken Watanabe), in his helicopter in Kyoto, when he first approaches Cobb about the possibility of inception. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. " And in case it was because Cobb did that by spinning the totem there too, then he should have been very confident to get into limbo every time. and wasn't Cobb drowning in the van and Saito had been shot and killed? But how did Cobb realized he was in limbo, when he and Mal were stuck there? Cobb (and Mal) were both dreaming experts working at the very cutting edge of dream technology and the PASIV machine. Together with her subsequent appearance in shared dreams with Ariadne, this begins to suggest that Cobb's subconscious projection of Mal is directly working against him - perhaps that she directly warned Saito. Explanation of how Cobb re-enters limbo twice and age. > He was already in limbo with Mal,. If dying in any level sends you to limbo (as they say it does due to the sedative), then his path would have been limbo -> 3 -> limbo, and the time dilation from one level would mean only a few hours have passed. I just watched Inception for the first time and wanted to share an interpretation that doesn't seem popular but makes a lot of sense to me. It is implied that he had therefore deliberately allowed himself to have the attempt at Extraction made on him and that he was prepared - by being mentally prepared he did not seem to store too many important secrets in the safe, and that he was suspicious of their approach to sell themselves as anti-extractors. 4.) When Cobb and Saito were in limbo, Cobb realized he was in Limbo because of the spinning totem. But that doesn't prove he is in the same spot as with Ariadne. And Cobb wouldn't have stopped Eames from shooting Saito. It seems that without Cobb directly rescuing Saito from limbo, he would have just died of old age, woken up in reality after mere minutes due to time dilation theory and shaken it off. How did Saito know he was under attack by extractors Cobb and Arthur in Inception? What should be included in error messages? At Level 1 when Saito is shot in the chest and Eames is about to shoot him in the head (in the warehouse) Cobb stops him saying that as they are all on sedatives killing him would send him to the limbo. But very definitely made of wool. When Cobb was stabbed by Mal in the fourth level, that is where Cobb died, and that is when Cobb reached limbo. Privacy Policy. When Cobb and Saito were in limbo, Cobb realized he was in Limbo because of the spinning totem. They wake up from limbo directly, just as Mal and Cobb once woke up directly from limbo. Novel about a man who moves between timelines. How did Cobb and Mal end up in Limbo to start with? Using the 1:20 ratio, 10 hours of reality actually equals 8.3 days of dreaming on the first level, 5.47 months on the second, and 9.1 years on the third. Saito says "are you here to kill me? In the movie 'Inception', how did Cobb and Saito come out of Limbo? Stained and frayed in such distinctive ways. What should be included in error messages? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. How Does Cobb And Saito Get Out Of Limbo? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Had he had to find the others as well, it's possible that one or more could have lost their minds before he was able to get to them. He couldn't He should be not scared about anyone dying in the mission, as he can go to limbo and not forget that he is still dreaming. Why didn't the team wake up from the multi-level kick? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Australia to west & east coast US: which order is better? Cobb convinces Saito, with the help of the spinning totem, of who he is and what they must do. The second time, after finding Saito, it seemed to be the same situation. It certainly took him (subjective) weeks and months to find Saito and when he found him, Saito was on the verge of dying (e.g. If he knew he were on a mission, and had only been on it for a few minutes, why would he take the time to eat? Cobb also realizes the totem is important and carries it, but he doesn't know what it does. Novel about a man who moves between timelines. Saito said: I've always hated this carpet. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Scan this QR code to download the app now. Mal represented the evil in Cobb. Later in the movie, they use the 'Mr Charles' gambit and deliberately make Fischer aware that he is in a dream. Cobb and Adraine entered the limbo state to get Fischer out of there. Cobb enters Limbo with Ariadne before Saito "dies" in the third dream level, so technically hasn't Cobb been in limbo for longer? Teen builds a spaceship and gets stuck on Mars; "Girl Next Door" uses his prototype to rescue him and also gets stuck on Mars. That's how he knew that it would work on Fischer. I prompt an AI into generating something; who created it: me, the AI, or the AI's author? Rewatched this for the first time since I saw it as a 14 year old in theaters and I have a few questions actually. In the first layer of the dream Saito knew that he was in a dream because of the Carpet. He knew where to find Fischer because he knew Mal would have him, and he knew Mal would be in the world they built together. What is the status for EIGHT man endgame tablebases? 1960s? Against Saito, who is prepared and has allowed himself to be introduced into a shared dream, maybe it is an approach that makes him become aware that he might be dreaming. Saito said: I've always hated this carpet. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. So why doesn't he give them Limbo training anyway, knowing that it's a risk? and "Erm, what else aren't you telling us?". Which means, I'm not lying on my carpet in my apartment. Just like how Cobb and Mal got out by lying on the train tracks. How to describe a scene that a small creature chop a large creature's head off? But eventually Saito dies of his bullet wound and Fischer too dies (atleast his heart stops beating). How did Cobb recognize he was dreaming the first time he and Mal went to Limbo? The usual explanation is that Cobb returned to level 1 and died in the van, and with three levels of time dilation, those few minutes for Cobb were years for Saito. On: July 7, 2022. I can't control it.". Does the paladin's Lay on Hands feature cure parasites? But very definitely made of wool. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Surely he would just get to the point. First off, the reason I don't like this explanation: how did Cobb get back to level 1? If it is the case that Limbo is infinite and it is difficult to 'find' anyone lost in limbo, Cobb could have trained the entire team to deal with limbo situation. And in case it was because Cobb did that by spinning the totem there too, then he should have been very confident to get into limbo every time. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. How does Ariadne 'riding' the kick differ to Cobb dying in the crumbling building? Is it usual and/or healthy for Ph.D. students to do part-time jobs outside academia? A: It's seems pretty clear from the context of the movie that Mal and Cobb were married and. Why doesn't Fischer recognize Arthur, Saito and Eames as kidnappers? Why Did Cobb And Mal Go Into Limbo? How exactly did Cobb and Saito make it out from Limbo? Many think Cobb has just arrived in limbo when he meets Saito because he washes up on the beach. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? In the first layer of the dream Saito knew that he was in a dream because of the Carpet. inception Share maybe I missed something, but didn't they miss the kicks? rev2023.6.29.43520. It is stated in scene in the apartment and reinforced in the helicopter scene following the failed attempt at Extraction that Saito was in-effect interviewing Cobb for the attempt at Inception, and that initially Saito thought that Cobb had failed the interview until he realized that they had put him in a two layer dream. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.