NAMI Mass Criminal Justice Diversion Project Finlay AK, Smelson D, Sawh L, McGuire J, Rosenthal J, Blue-Howells J, Timko C, Binswanger I, Frayne SM, Blodgett JC, Bowe T, Clark SC, Harris AHS. Program completion was the strongest predictor of incarceration followed by the number of days spent incarcerated during the 12 months prior to diversion as the second strongest predictor. EDCOT would also require significant improvements in the outpatient and inpatient mental health resources available to diverted individuals. Among noncompleters, approximately 51% (n = 37) refused services or were noncompliant, another 15% (n = 11) were lost to contact, 6% (n = 4) were deceased, and the remaining 28% (n = 20) were coded by the prosecutor's office as other reasons with no further details specified. Additionally, they serve longer sentences and their incarcerations are more costly, perhaps due to the lack of adequate treatment [3]. Jail Diversion Models: Part 1 | Office of Justice Programs While these challenges make it difficult to determine a specific prevalence rate, a recent systematic review concludes that for numerous mental illnesses the prevalence rate is elevated among incarcerated populations compared to the general population, and sometimes this rate is substantially higher [2]. A national survey of jail diversion programs for mentally ill - PubMed Noncompleters averaged 2.02 annually arrests up to 5 years after enrollment in the jail diversion program, whereas completers averaged 0.63 arrests (F(1,124) = 5.62, p < .05). What was revealed was an embarrassingly dysfunctional system. In the fifth year, the proportion remaining in the community without any arrest drops to virtually the same for both groups. Program results demonstrate that individualized transition planning to access necessary community-based treatment and services upon release fromjail will ensure successful community re-entry and recovery for individuals with mental illnesses, and possible co-occurring substance use disorders that are involved in the criminal justice system. The program operates two primary components:prebooking jail diversion consisting of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) training for law enforcement officers and postbooking jail diversion serving individuals booked into the county jail and awaiting adjudication. We do not capture any email address. Most AOT programs only mandate treatment for six or 12 months, though this may be renewed if the patient has remained in treatment and still meets the criteria for involuntary outpatient commitment. The CMHP has demonstrated substantial, cost-effective gains in the effort to reverse the criminalization of people with mental illnesses. Since 2008, the number of annual jail bookings has decreased from roughly 118 000 to 53 000 last year (see Figure 1). Copyright 2021 Miami Foundation for Mental Health. All of the more effective, evidenced-based community services including assertive community treatment (ACT), supportive housing, and supported employment are long-term. Objectives: The authors sought information on the number, structure, and effectiveness of programs aimed at diverting mentally ill inmates from the criminal justice system into the mental health treatment system. When these programs are not based in the prosecutor's office, typically defense counsel and a behavioral health care provider have to advocate with a potentially reluctant prosecutor to consider this option. Sign In to Email Alerts with your Email Address. RTI uses cookies to offer you the best experience online. The DC Superior Court Mental Health Community Court (MHCC) is a voluntary treatment court for people who have been diagnosed with serious and persistent mental illness, who are charged with certain misdemeanor or low-level felony offenses, and who otherwise qualify for the MHCC program. Steadman H, Morris S & Dennis D 1995. Monthly cumulative proportion of persons (completers versus noncompleters) remaining in community without any arrests over 60 months. sharing sensitive information, make sure youre on a federal Those who are identified as being in possible psychiatric distress are referred to corrections health services psychiatric staff for more thorough evaluation. Many participants were shocked to find that a single person with mental illness was accessing the services of TABLE 1. The program helps divert individuals from the criminal justice system to more appropriate mental health services. Sacks S., Cleland C. M., Melnick G., et al. Pre-charge diversion. government site. GLOF is a measure developed by the New Jersey Division of Mental Health Services (NJ DMHS) to provide an overall assessment of community functioning and coping with symptomatology. Abramson M. F. The criminalization of mentally disordered behavior: possible side-effect of a new mental health law. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. PDF Jail diversion: the Miami model - Florida Courts Diversion aims to reverse the criminalization of mental illness that has been such a large, and growing, problem in the United States over the past several decades.1 When public safety can be protected without incarceration, and an individual's offense was driven to a substantial degree by symptoms of an untreated or inadequately treated mental illness, it is both just and a prudent use of public resources to divert that individual to treatment in a community setting. Miami-Dade County: Heavy User Data Analysis (n = 97). The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the Hoge and Bonnie specifically mention murder and armed robbery, but it is safe to assume that defendants with other serious charges such as attempted murder, kidnapping or rape, which could lead to sentences counted in decades (or a life term) would also be excluded from consideration. The post hoc grouping of completers versus noncompleters has its limitations because of the high degree of self-selection and other factors such as preexisting differences that contribute to whether someone remains in the program. Participants who are noncompleters are at significantly higher risk for reincarceration after entering the jail diversion program through year three (see Figure 3). Both groups (program completers and noncompleters) had their sharpest gains while still actively enrolled in the service and completers who received services for a longer length of time sustained these gains longer. RTI International is a trade name of Research Triangle Institute. Copyright 2023 by The American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law. In addition, since 2010, the CMHP has worked closely with ThrivingMind South Florida, which contracts with the state to administer non-Medicaid, mental health, and substance abuse treatment state funding for the uninsured and underinsured in Miami-Dade and Monroe Counties. Jail-based diversion is one of three general types of postbooking diversion (Broner, Borum, and Gawley, 2002 as cited in [17]). 0:00. By housing a comprehensive array of services and supports in one location, and providing re-entry assistance upon discharge to the community, it is anticipated that many of the barriers and obstacles to navigating traditional community mental health and social services will be eliminated. The Union County Prosecutor's Office compiled data regarding the types of arrests and convictions, jail/prison days, dates of jail admission and release, and total jail days (both lifetime prior to diversion and that from diversion through April 2011, allowing for up to 60 months of follow-up). Cases with missing data for a particular analysis were excluded. This article is a review of the research literature Since August 2009, the CMHP has overseen the implementation of the Miami-Dade Forensic Alternative Center (MD-FAC) to divert individuals with mental illnesses committed to the Florida Department of Children and Families from placement in state forensic hospitals to placement in community-based treatment and forensic services. Harm Reduct J. Integrating the criminal justice system into mental health service delivery: the worcester diversion experience. Cloyes K. G., Wong B., Latimer S., Abarca J. Many existing diversion programs lack sufficient authority to ensure treatment compliance, and incarceration is their primary response to deviation from program rules. In many states, the competency to stand trial (CST) system is being overwhelmed by an ever-increasing number of referrals, leading to long delays in adjudication of the original charges.5. In criminal justice, mental health diversion is a term used to refer to a variety of approaches to reduce the arrest and incarceration of individuals with mental illness. Other modifiable risk factors, such as homelessness, substance abuse, and employment, also need to be targeted in efforts to reduce subsequent arrests [12]. Crim Justice Policy Rev. Peterson J. K., Skeem J., Kennealy P., Bray B., Zvonkovic A. The goal is to support community living, reduce maladaptive behaviors, and decrease the chances that individuals will re-offend and reappear in the criminal justice system. While other programs rely on the involvement of the prosecutor, few are run out of the prosecutor's office. The long-term benefits include reduced demand for costly acute care services in jails, prisons, forensic mental health treatment facilities, emergency rooms, and other crisis settings; decreased crime and improved public safety; improved public health; decreased injuries to law enforcement officers, and people with mental illnesses; and decreased rates of chronic homelessness. Those with scores of four through six are increasing their level of independent functioning and coping, although they may occasionally be hospitalized or in supervised settings. Crim Behav Ment Health. The CMHP provides an effective, cost-efficient solution to a community problem and works by eliminating gaps in services, and by forging productive and innovative relationships among all stakeholders who have an interest in the welfare and safety of one of our communitys most vulnerable populations. A Radical New Approach for Mental Health Diversion, Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law Online, DOI: https://doi.org/10.29158/JAAPL.210106-21, The prevalence of mental illness in California jails is rising: An analysis of mental health cases & psychotropic medication prescriptions, 20092019 [Internet], Custody Division Reports: Mental Health Count [Internet], Expedited diversion of criminal defendants to court-ordered treatment, Challenges to reforming the competence to stand trial and competence restoration system, Resolution or resignation: The role of forensic mental health professionals amidst the competency services crisis, Just and well: Rethinking how states approach competency to stand trial, The Council of State Governments Justice Center, Evaluation and restoration of competence to stand trial: Intercepting the forensic system using the sequential intercept model, A survey of national trends in psychiatric patients found incompetent to stand trial: Reasons for the reinstitutionalization of people with serious mental illness in the United States, California capitol watch: Assisted outpatient treatmentbill would loosen criteria for involuntary mental health treatment, Ethics Considerations in Laws Restricting Incapacitated Patients' Access to ECT, A Proposal for the Capacity to Stipulate to Civil Commitment and a 50-State Review of Statutes, Psychiatric and Substance-Related Problems Predict Recidivism for First-Time Justice-Involved Youth, by The American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, https://lasd.org/transparency/custodyreports/#2021_mental_count, https://csgjusticecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Just-and-Well27OCT2020.pdf, http://www.bazelon.org/our-work/mental-health-systems/forced-treatment/, https://www.davisvanguard.org/2021/07/california-capitol-watch-assisted-outpatient-treatment-bill-would-loosen-criteria-for-involuntary-mental-health-treatment/, 2021 American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law. Jail Diversion Services. Short-term benefits include reduced numbers of defendants with SMI in the county jail, as well as more efficient and effective access to housing, treatment, and wraparound services for individuals re-entering the community. Treatment included initial evaluation and diagnosis, psychotropic medication monitoring if prescribed, and additional individualized treatments. PDF Jail Diversion Practice Guidelines (P.7.10.3.10) - State of Michigan The legal disposition of the diversions included reduced sentences (15%), dismissal of charges (13%), downgrading or reduction of charges to a less serious charge (58%), or pretrial interventions (14%). Instead of punishment, pre-arrest diversion steers people toward treatment and support for their mental health problems. CMHP staff assess, plan, identify, and coordinate transition plans that are individualized for each program participant. Accessibility The findings suggest that early involvement in jail diversion services is advisable before individuals develop a cycle of numerous arrests and periods of incarceration (McNeil & Binder, 2007). official website and that any information you provide is encrypted The strongest gains were seen while the individual was still actively enrolled in the diversion services and these outcomes were maintained for up to four years. These diversions took place at a variety of stages. The criminalization of mental illness is a national tragedy. Funding for staff positions comes fromcounty, state, and federal sources and consists of a mix of general revenue and grant funding. Individuals who voluntarily agree to services are assisted with linkages to a comprehensive array of community-based treatment, support, and housing services that are essential for successful community re-entry and recovery outcomes. To date, theCMHP has provided CIT training to more than 7000 law enforcement officers from all 36 local municipalities in Miami-Dade County, as well as Miami-Dade Public Schools and the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. In addition, the cumulative proportion of persons still not arrested at 60 months is almost equal to that of noncompleters, although their incarceration days and incidence of incarceration remain significantly lower. Diversion programs are initiatives in which persons with serious mental illness who are involved with the criminal justice system are redirected from traditional criminal justice pathways to the mental health and substance abuse treatment systems. Every day, in every community in the United States, law enforcement agencies, courts, and correctional institutions are witness to a parade of misery brought on by untreated or under-treated mental illnesses. Effects of serious mental illness and substance abuse on criminal offenses. Using logistic regression, forward stepwise method, both number of jail days in the prior year and program completion predicted whether someone was jailed or not on any occasion after diversion (2(2) = 41.79, p < .001). Our Rochester Regional Health's Jail diversion program is the only program of its kind in New York State. NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person you are recommending the page to knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. 2006;24(6):845-56. doi: 10.1002/bsl.738. In large part, this is not a surprising finding in light of other treatment services' research for persons with serious mental illness. By clicking accept on this website, you opt in and you agree to the use of cookies. Curr Opin Psychiatry. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. To illustrate the inefficient and costly consequences of the current system, researchers from the Florida Mental Health Institute at the University of South Florida examined arrest, incarceration, acute care, and inpatient service utilization rates among 97 individuals with SMIs participating in jail diversion programs in Miami-Dade County, FL. Information from this planning study was used to develop a more formal program design and to secure a federal grant in 2003, which enabled the CMHP to significantly expand its staffing and operations. This has been particularly effective in resolving problems that arise from poor communication and cross-systems fragmentation. About Our Co-Response jail diversion Model The Model Advocates operates pre-arrest Co-Response Programs in multiple police departments across Massachusetts. Jail Diversion Program | Rochester Regional Health Social determinants of mental health care systems: intensive community based Care in the Veterans Health Administration. Ironically, while many individuals could not access themost basic prevention and treatment services in the community, they were being provided the costliest levels of crisis and emergency care over and over again. Other outpatient services and inpatient care were provided. Additional Programs - AGENCY FOR COMMUNITY TREATMENT SERVICES, INC. A structured literature search identified 21 publications or research papers for review that examined the criminal justice outcomes of various diversion models. The treatment provider also assists individuals in accessing entitlement benefits and other means of economic self-sufficiency to ensure ongoing and timely access to services and supports after re-entering the community. Consistently a higher cumulative proportion of program completers are maintained in the community without arrest for four years. For Mentally Ill, Jail Diversion Program Gives Second Chance Prevalence of mental illnesses in U.S. state prisons: A systematic review. The county jail currently serves as the largest psychiatric institution in Florida and contains as many beds serving inmates with mental illnesses as all state civil and forensic mental health hospitals combined. Careers, Unable to load your collection due to an error. Thus, its use in less serious criminal cases, or when the patient is already close to achieving competency, often proves counterproductive, as defendants end up waiting in jail for long periods, while typically not receiving robust services once their criminal proceedings and sentence ultimately conclude. The police were policing, the lawyers were lawyering, and the judges were judging. The best outcomes were found in the first follow-up year. Access to entitlement benefits is an essential element in successful recovery and community reintegration for many justice system involved individuals with serious mental illnesses. According to the most recent prevalence estimates, roughly 16.9% of jail detainees (14.5% of men and 31.0% of women) experience serious mental illnesses (SMI).Considering that in 2018 law enforcement nationwide made an estimated 10.3 million arrests,2 this suggests that more than 1.7 million involved people with SMIs. Mental Health Clinician (LCPC, LCSW-C) for the Hospital and Jail The purpose of JDPs is to de-escalate encounters with mentally ill offenders and create a cooperative environment for assessing the situation. Mental Health Jail Diversion is a project in Harris County designed to help people with mental health diagnoses get services without going to jail. In fact, completers and noncompleters had significant differences even before entering the service, with noncompleters having more extensive criminal justice histories and a higher likelihood of having a substance abuse diagnosis. The decreases in days incarcerated and number of arrests are comparable to that of previous studies. There is, however, support for its validity from one study [19]. Pre-Arrest Diversion Program for People Experiencing a Mental Health Crisis, Bilateral Agencies and Multilateral Banks, Universities and Academic Research Institutions, Child and Adolescent Research and Evaluation Program, Social and Economic Justice Research Collaborative, Narrative Research and Community Engagement Lab, Career and Adult Education and Workforce Development, Education Policy, Systems, and Governance, Global Food Security, Agriculture, and Nutrition, Monitoring, Evaluation, Research, Learning, and Adapting (MERLA), RTI Center for Global Noncommunicable Diseases, Climate Planning, Preparedness and Resilience, Climate Vulnerability, Adaptation, and Mitigation, Sustainable Materials & Waste Management Solutions, Community Safety, Crime Prevention, and Victimization Response, RTI Center for Policing Research and Investigative Science, Child Well-Being and Family Strengthening, Evidence-Based Strategies to Reduce Firearm Violence, Innovation for Emerging and Developing Economies, Research, Technology, and Innovation Policy, Military Sexual Assault, Harassment, and Domestic Violence Prevention, North Carolina Center for Optimizing Military Performance, Coordinating Centers for Multisite Studies, Advanced Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods, Evaluating Communication Interventions and Campaigns, Evidence Synthesis for Policy and Practice, Curriculum and Teacher Professional Development, Human-Centered Design of Digital Solutions, Data Management and Decision Support Systems, Geospatial Science, Technology, and Visualization, Drug Metabolism and Pharmacokinetics (DMPK), In Vitro Pharmacology, Bioassay Development, and High-Throughput Screening (HTS), Regulatory Consulting and Support for Medical Products, Proficiency Testing and Reference Materials, Policing Research and Investigative Science, Lafayette Parish (Louisiana) Sheriff's Office, More mental health services provided to eligible subjects, Fewer people ending up in jail after mental health crises, A lower proportion of law enforcement calls for service based on mental health crises. Each additional day of prior jail admissions increased the likelihood of any postdiversion admission by 2.8% (odds-ratio = 1.028). However, for each follow-up period, noncompleters spent more days in jail than completers. Persons with mental illness are over-represented in the criminal justice system.